Best Assisted Living Facilities in Bay Shore, NY

Find local assisted living and retirement communities in the Bay Shore, NY area.

In Bay Shore, New York, seniors comprise about 30.4% of the population, making the need for excellent senior living options a significant focus. The area provides three senior living facilities, with a broader scope of 676 more in the surrounding region, offering a variety of choices from independent living to comprehensive nursing care. Assisted living in Bay Shore averages $6,152 per month, reflecting the area's focus on quality care and living arrangements. This guide will introduce you to some of the top assisted living communities in Bay Shore, helping you determine the best fit for your loved one's needs and ensuring they receive exceptional care and support.

360 Communities were found near Bay Shore, NY
Atria Bay Shore
Our Rating:
of 5
5

Atria Bay Shore

53 Ocean Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706 (0.8 mi from city center)
Assisted Living Independent Living Memory Care Senior Apartments

Atria Bay Shore offers independent living, supportive living, and memory care in a grand community building near the picturesque Great South Bay.

View All Amenities See Available Rooms
Our Rating:
of 5
5
Housekeeping services
Pet-friendly
Concierge services
Meals
Dining room
Fitness center and classes
Outdoor areas
Library
Laundry services
Social and common areas
Transportation services
Studio - Request A Quote For Details
One Bedroom - Request A Quote For Details
Two Bedroom - Request A Quote For Details
Sunrise Manor Nursing Home
Our Rating:
of 5
5

Sunrise Manor Nursing Home

1325 Brentwood Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706 (1 mi from city center)
Nursing Home

Sunrise Manor is an intimate 84-bed center for nursing and rehabilitation conveniently located on Suffolk County's South Shore.

Our Rating:
of 5
5
Pearl Garden Manor
Our Rating:
of 5
5

Pearl Garden Manor

36 Locust Ave, Islip, NY 11751 (1.9 mi from city center)
Assisted Living Residential Care Home

Pearl Garden Manor is an Assisted Living community located at 36 Locust Avenue in Islip, NY.

View All Amenities
Our Rating:
of 5
5
Meals
Dining room
Pleasantview Home for Adults
Our Rating:
of 5
5

Pleasantview Home for Adults

70 Massachusetts Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706 (2 mi from city center)
Assisted Living Memory Care Residential Care Home

Pleasantview Home for Adults is a cozy assisted living community located in a residential neighborhood in Bay Shore, New York, specializing in memory care and providing personalized care and attention to its residents.

View All Amenities See Available Rooms
Our Rating:
of 5
5
Housekeeping services
Wi-Fi
Meals
Fitness center and classes
Beauty salon/Barber shop
Art classes
Outdoor areas
Library
Laundry services
Gardening
Social and common areas
Transportation services
Studio - Starting at $6,500 per month
One Bedroom - Starting at $4,000 per month
Shared Bedroom - Starting at $3,500 per month
Seniorcare Companions
Our Rating:
of 5
4.5

Seniorcare Companions

152 Islip Ave # 25, Islip, NY 11751 (2.2 mi from city center)
Home Care

SeniorCare Companions provides quality home care services on Long Island, NY, offering flexible scheduling and comprehensive caregiver screening.

View All Amenities
Our Rating:
of 5
4.5
Housekeeping services
Transportation services
Our Lady-Consolation Nrsng Hm
Our Rating:
of 5
3.5

Our Lady-Consolation Nrsng Hm

111 Beach Dr, West Islip, NY 11795 (3.5 mi from city center)
Assisted Living Memory Care Nursing Home

Our Lady of Consolation Nursing & Rehabilitative Care Center is a nonprofit nursing home in West Islip, NY, offering 450 certified beds and a range of care services.

View All Amenities See Available Rooms
Our Rating:
of 5
3.5
Housekeeping services
Wi-Fi
Pet-friendly
Meals
Dining room
Outdoor areas
Social and common areas
Transportation services
Shared Bedroom - Request A Quote For Details
Ross Healthcare Center
Our Rating:
of 5
3.5

Ross Healthcare Center

839 Suffolk Ave, Brentwood, NY 11717 (3.8 mi from city center)
Nursing Home

Ross Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation is a 120-bed, family-owned Skilled Nursing Facility committed to compassionate care, offering a comprehensive array of specialized services and clinical programs.

View All Amenities See Available Rooms
Our Rating:
of 5
3.5
Housekeeping services
Meals
Dining room
Laundry services
Social and common areas
Shared Bedroom - Request A Quote For Details

Need Help Finding the Right Community?

Answer a few questions to get personalized recommendations
Attentive Care
Our Rating:
of 5
4

Attentive Care

375 Deer Park Ave, Babylon, NY 11702 (4.2 mi from city center)
Home Care

Attentive Care provides high-quality home care services to seniors in their homes, hospitals, or nursing homes.

View All Amenities
Our Rating:
of 5
4
Housekeeping services
Babylon Beach House
Our Rating:
of 5
4

Babylon Beach House

23 Yacht Club Rd, Babylon, NY 11702 (4.6 mi from city center)
Assisted Living Residential Care Home

The Babylon Beach House is a waterfront senior community providing elder care and services in a nurturing, supportive, and active environment.

View All Amenities See Available Rooms
Our Rating:
of 5
4
Housekeeping services
Meals
Dining room
Beauty salon/Barber shop
Outdoor areas
Laundry services
Social and common areas
Shared Bedroom - Request A Quote For Details
The Arbors at Hauppauge
Our Rating:
of 5
5

The Arbors at Hauppauge

1740 Express Dr S, Hauppauge, NY 11788 (5.4 mi from city center)
Assisted Living Independent Living Memory Care

The Arbors at Hauppauge is a senior living community offering assisted living, memory care, and independent living options in Hauppauge, NY.

View All Amenities See Available Rooms
Our Rating:
of 5
5
Housekeeping services
Wi-Fi
Pet-friendly
Meals
Dining room
Fitness center and classes
Beauty salon/Barber shop
Technology center
Art classes
Outdoor areas
Guest parking
Social and common areas
Transportation services
Studio - Request A Quote For Details
Shared Bedroom - Request A Quote For Details
Family First Home Companions, LLC
Our Rating:
of 5
5

Family First Home Companions, LLC

150 Vanderbilt Motor Parkway Suite 401, Hauppauge, NY 11788 (5.4 mi from city center)
Home Care

Family First Home Companions, LLC provides non-medical home care services to seniors and individuals with disabilities in Hauppauge, NY.

View All Amenities
Our Rating:
of 5
5
Housekeeping services
Laundry services
Transportation services
The Bristal at West Babylon
Our Rating:
of 5
3

The Bristal at West Babylon

520 Montauk Hwy, West Babylon, NY 11704 (5.5 mi from city center)
Assisted Living Independent Living Memory Care

The Bristal at West Babylon offers luxurious services and amenities for the finest senior living experience, including assisted living, memory care, and independent living.

View All Amenities See Available Rooms
Our Rating:
of 5
3
Housekeeping services
Pet-friendly
Pool
Meals
Dining room
Fitness center and classes
Beauty salon/Barber shop
Outdoor areas
Library
Laundry services
Screening room
Social and common areas
Transportation services
Studio - Starting at $4,700 per month
One Bedroom - Request A Quote For Details
Two Bedroom - Request A Quote For Details
Shared Bedroom - Request A Quote For Details
Sunrise of West Babylon
Our Rating:
of 5
4.5

Sunrise of West Babylon

580 Montauk Highway, West Babylon, NY 11704 (5.7 mi from city center)
Assisted Living Memory Care

Sunrise of West Babylon is a senior living community offering assisted living and memory care services.

View All Amenities See Available Rooms
Our Rating:
of 5
4.5
Housekeeping services
Wi-Fi
Pet-friendly
Concierge services
Meals
Dining room
Beauty salon/Barber shop
Art classes
Outdoor areas
Resident parking
Guest parking
Library
Laundry services
Social and common areas
Transportation services
Studio - Request A Quote For Details
One Bedroom - Request A Quote For Details
Two Bedroom - Request A Quote For Details
The Cornerstone at Hauppauge
Our Rating:
of 5
5

The Cornerstone at Hauppauge

135 Stonehenge Ln, Hauppauge, NY 11788 (6.4 mi from city center)
Independent Living Senior Apartments

The Cornerstone at Hauppauge is a 55 and over active adult community located in Suffolk County, NY, offering one and two-bedroom apartments with various amenities.

View All Amenities See Available Rooms
Our Rating:
of 5
5
Pet-friendly
Dining room
Fitness center and classes
Technology center
Outdoor areas
Resident parking
Laundry services
Gardening
Social and common areas
One Bedroom - Starting at $3,125 per month
Two Bedroom - Starting at $3,202 per month
Home Instead Senior Care - Hauppauge, NY
Our Rating:
of 5
5

Home Instead Senior Care - Hauppauge, NY

900 Wheeler Rd Suite 240, Hauppauge, NY 11788 (6.4 mi from city center)
Home Care Memory Care

Home Instead Senior Care provides in-home senior care services tailored to meet the needs of aging adults in Hauppauge, NY.

View All Amenities
Our Rating:
of 5
5
Transportation services
The Arbors at Islandia - East and West
Our Rating:
of 5
4.5

The Arbors at Islandia - East and West

1515 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Islandia, NY 11749 (6.6 mi from city center)
Assisted Living Memory Care

The Arbors at Islandia - East and West is a senior living community offering assisted living and memory care services.

View All Amenities See Available Rooms
Our Rating:
of 5
4.5
Housekeeping services
Meals
Dining room
Fitness center and classes
Beauty salon/Barber shop
Art classes
Outdoor areas
Gardening
Social and common areas
Studio - Request A Quote For Details
One Bedroom - Request A Quote For Details
Shared Bedroom - Request A Quote For Details
Gurwin Jewish- Fay J. Lindner Residences
Our Rating:
of 5
3

Gurwin Jewish- Fay J. Lindner Residences

50 Hauppauge Road, Commack, NY 11725 (7.4 mi from city center)
Assisted Living Independent Living Memory Care Nursing Home

Gurwin Jewish~Fay J. Lindner Residences is a Long Island assisted living community offering luxurious and elegant living spaces, comprehensive care services, and a variety of activities and amenities.

View All Amenities See Available Rooms
Our Rating:
of 5
3
Housekeeping services
Wi-Fi
Pet-friendly
Pool
Meals
Dining room
Fitness center and classes
Beauty salon/Barber shop
Technology center
Art classes
Outdoor areas
Laundry services
Social and common areas
Transportation services
Studio - Request A Quote For Details
One Bedroom - Starting at $4,950 per month
Two Bedroom - Request A Quote For Details
Helping Hearts at Home, NY
Our Rating:
of 5
4.5

Helping Hearts at Home, NY

496 Smithtown Bypass Suite 201, Smithtown, NY 11787 (7.5 mi from city center)
Home Care

Helping Hearts at Home provides non-medical home care services to seniors, including companionship, light housekeeping, meal preparation, and assistance with daily tasks.

View All Amenities
Our Rating:
of 5
4.5
Housekeeping services
Concierge services
Sunrise of Dix Hills
Our Rating:
of 5
5

Sunrise of Dix Hills

337 Deer Park Avenue, Dix Hills, NY 11746 (7.7 mi from city center)
Assisted Living Home Care Memory Care

Sunrise of Dix Hills is a senior living community offering assisted living, memory care, and short-term stays in a Victorian-style estate with personalized care and engaging activities.

View All Amenities See Available Rooms
Our Rating:
of 5
5
Housekeeping services
Wi-Fi
Pet-friendly
Meals
Dining room
Fitness center and classes
Beauty salon/Barber shop
Art classes
Outdoor areas
Guest parking
Laundry services
Gardening
Social and common areas
Transportation services
Studio - Starting at $5,259 per month
One Bedroom - Starting at $5,685 per month
Two Bedroom - Starting at $6,384 per month
Shared Bedroom - Starting at $8,786 per month
The Arbors at Bohemia
Our Rating:
of 5
5

The Arbors at Bohemia

1065 Smithtown Ave, Bohemia, NY 11716 (8 mi from city center)
Assisted Living Independent Living Memory Care

The Arbors at Bohemia is a unique, resort-like independent and assisted living community for active seniors.

View All Amenities See Available Rooms
Our Rating:
of 5
5
Housekeeping services
Pet-friendly
Meals
Dining room
Beauty salon/Barber shop
Outdoor areas
Guest parking
Laundry services
Social and common areas
Transportation services
Studio - Request A Quote For Details
One Bedroom - Request A Quote For Details
Shared Bedroom - Request A Quote For Details
Dominican Village
Our Rating:
of 5
4

Dominican Village

565 Albany Avenue, Amityville, NY 11701 (8.1 mi from city center)
Assisted Living Independent Living Memory Care

Dominican Village is a not-for-profit, non-sectarian, rental retirement community and assisted living residence providing a supportive environment that fosters independence and promotes physical, mental, emotional, and spiritual health.

View All Amenities See Available Rooms
Our Rating:
of 5
4
Housekeeping services
Wi-Fi
Pet-friendly
Meals
Dining room
Beauty salon/Barber shop
Outdoor areas
Library
Social and common areas
Transportation services
Studio - Request A Quote For Details
One Bedroom - Request A Quote For Details
Artis Senior Living of Commack
Our Rating:
of 5
4.5

Artis Senior Living of Commack

1131 Jericho Turnpike, Commack, NY 11725 (8.2 mi from city center)
Memory Care

Artis Senior Living of Commack provides compassionate, premier Memory Care in Suffolk County, NY, with a person-centered approach to care.

View All Amenities See Available Rooms
Our Rating:
of 5
4.5
Housekeeping services
Concierge services
Meals
Dining room
Art classes
Outdoor areas
Guest parking
Laundry services
Social and common areas
Studio - Request A Quote For Details
The Bristal at East Northport
Our Rating:
of 5
4.5

The Bristal at East Northport

760 Larkfield Road East, Northport, NY 11731 (8.3 mi from city center)
Assisted Living Independent Living Memory Care

The Bristal at East Northport is a luxury senior living community offering assisted living, Alzheimer's care, memory care, and more.

View All Amenities See Available Rooms
Our Rating:
of 5
4.5
Housekeeping services
Pet-friendly
Pool
Meals
Dining room
Fitness center and classes
Beauty salon/Barber shop
Technology center
Outdoor areas
Resident parking
Guest parking
Laundry services
Screening room
Social and common areas
Transportation services
Studio - Request A Quote For Details
One Bedroom - Request A Quote For Details
Two Bedroom - Request A Quote For Details
Shared Bedroom - Starting at $6,500 per month
Jens Family Type Home for Adults
Our Rating:
of 5
5

Jens Family Type Home for Adults

7 Roosevelt Dr, Smithtown, NY 11787 (8.5 mi from city center)
Memory Care Residential Care Home

Jens Family Type Home for Adults is a residential care home located in Smithtown, NY.

See Available Rooms
Our Rating:
of 5
5
Shared Bedroom - Request A Quote For Details
The Bristal at Sayville
Our Rating:
of 5
4.5

The Bristal at Sayville

129 Lakeland Avenue, Sayville, NY 11782 (8.6 mi from city center)
Assisted Living Independent Living Memory Care

The Bristal at Sayville offers assisted living, memory care, and independent living with various amenities and services.

View All Amenities See Available Rooms
Our Rating:
of 5
4.5
Housekeeping services
Pet-friendly
Meals
Dining room
Outdoor areas
Social and common areas
Studio - Request A Quote For Details
One Bedroom - Request A Quote For Details
Two Bedroom - Request A Quote For Details
Shared Bedroom - Starting at $5,800 per month

Map of Assisted Living in Bay Shore

Find the right senior living community by location
  • Atria Bay Shore
  • Sunrise Manor Nursing Home
  • Pearl Garden Manor
  • Pleasantview Home for Adults
  • Seniorcare Companions
  • Our Lady-Consolation Nrsng Hm
  • Ross Healthcare Center
  • Attentive Care
  • Babylon Beach House
  • The Arbors at Hauppauge
  • Family First Home Companions, LLC
  • The Bristal at West Babylon
  • Sunrise of West Babylon
  • The Cornerstone at Hauppauge
  • Home Instead Senior Care - Hauppauge, NY
  • The Arbors at Islandia - East and West
  • Gurwin Jewish- Fay J. Lindner Residences
  • Helping Hearts at Home, NY
  • Sunrise of Dix Hills
  • The Arbors at Bohemia
  • Dominican Village
  • Artis Senior Living of Commack
  • The Bristal at East Northport
  • Jens Family Type Home for Adults
  • The Bristal at Sayville

Senior Living Statistics for Bay Shore, New York

Average Senior Living Costs by Housing Type


In Bay Shore, New York, the least expensive senior living option is a detached cottage, starting at $3,500 per month. The most costly type of senior living is a two-bedroom unit in a nursing home, which averages $9,216 per month. Several other options offer a range of price points, including assisted living at $6,152 per month and memory care at $6,371 per month. For those interested in independent living, it costs an average of $6,077 per month. Nursing home choices include a private room at $5,167, a semi-private room for $5,440, a studio at $7,226, and a one-bedroom for $8,381. Bay Shore caters to diverse preferences with an array of senior housing options.
Housing Type Average Monthly Cost
Assisted Living $6,152
Memory Care $6,371
Independent Living $6,077
Nursing Home: Private Room $5,167
Nursing Home: Semi-Private Room $5,440
Nursing Home: Studio $7,226
Nursing Home: One Bedroom $8,381
Nursing Home: Two Bedroom $9,216
Nursing Home: Detached Cottage $3,500

Average Cost of Assisted Living in Bay Shore


Assisted living costs in Bay Shore average $6,152 per month, which is a few hundred dollars more than the cost in nearby cities. For example, the average cost of assisted living in Patchogue is $5,683, which is $469 less than Bay Shore, while Bellport costs $5,597, making it $555 less.
City Average Monthly Cost
Bay Shore $6,152
Patchogue $5,683
Bellport $5,597

Here is how the average cost of assisted living in Bay Shore compares to New York and the national average:
Area Average Monthly Cost
Bay Shore $6,152
New York $5,545
United States $4,546

Senior Living Availability in Bay Shore


Bay Shore offers 3 of the 748 senior living communities in New York. If you decide to extend your search to the cities near Bay Shore, there are 676 facilities available. With these choices, you can find the ideal community to meet your needs.
3

Bay Shore

676

Surrounding Area

748

New York

Bay Shore Senior Demographics


In Bay Shore, New York, seniors represent 30.4% of the total population of 30,553 residents. The gender distribution is slightly in favor of males, with 51.3% male and 48.7% female. Among seniors, 11.8% are in their 50s, 9.4% in their 60s, 5.6% in their 70s, and 3.6% are 80 and over. Regarding marital status, 40.6% of the seniors are married, 11.7% are divorced, 40.2% never married, and 7.5% are widowed. Bay Shore showcases a rich tapestry of diversity, with 52.3% identifying as White, 33.2% as Hispanic, and 15.4% as Black. The community also includes 9% Asian, 9.6% mixed race, 1.7% Native American, and a prominent 12.1% identifying as other, adding vibrant cultural dynamics to the area.

Population

Bay Shore has a population of 30,553.
  • 51.3% Male
  • 48.7% Female

Marital Status

  • 40.6% Married
  • 11.7% Divorced
  • 40.2% Never Married
  • 7.5% Widowed

Age

Seniors make up about 30.4% of the population.
  • 11.8% in their 50s
  • 9.4% in their 60s
  • 5.6% in their 70s
  • 3.6% in their 80s

Diversity

  • 52.3% White
  • 15.4% Black
  • 9% Asian
  • 1.7% Native
  • 12.1% Identifying as Other
  • 9.6% Mixed Race
  • 33.2% Hispanic

Additional Cities with Assisted Living Near Bay Shore

Several neighboring cities offer senior living options around Bay Shore, New York, with a variety of price points. Smithtown provides one of the more affordable choices at $6,433 per month, while East Brunswick tops the list at $7,711. Cities like New York and the Bronx are priced close together, at $6,871 and $6,861, respectively. In the mid-range, Plainview offers pricing at $6,345. Whether you're looking for budget-friendly options or premium living spaces, these cities cater to diverse needs and preferences.

City Average Monthly Cost
City Average Monthly Cost
New York $6,871
Bronx $6,861
Brick $7,308
Wayne $7,437
Toms River $7,356
West Orange $7,242
Lakewood $7,370
Edison $6,995
East Orange $7,248
City Average Monthly Cost
Freehold $7,321
Paramus $7,343
Smithtown $6,433
New Rochelle $6,893
East Brunswick $7,711
Montclair $7,235
Livingston $7,602
Plainview $6,345
Jackson $7,360

Senior Living Ratings Methodology

Our experts spent over 50 hours researching the best communities in each city, focusing on these key factors.

Senior Living Ratings Methodology

Available Care

We value communities that offer more than standard living services, such as memory care and independent living. We think this is beneficial for older adults, as it allows a community to meet your changing needs over time.

Amenities

Amenities can help an assisted living community feel like a luxury resort or a home away from home. Our research focuses on communities that offer extra perks and benefits for seniors to enjoy.

Location

Location can be important. Since many seniors like to have certain comforts nearby, we look at communities close to parks, shopping areas, hospitals, museums, and other practical or entertaining points of interest.

Reviews

We read through dozens of reviews for every single contender and include a summary of our findings. In most cases, we see common themes regarding positive and negative feedback about each community. Just remember not to take individual reviews at face value.

Cost

Assisted living costs vary greatly based on the facility and level of care. We considered communities that are suitable for various budgets and offer solid value. All prices listed are from community websites.