SeniorLiving.org’s Best Recommendations for Medicare Part D Plans

Our Experience With Humana Part D

Humana has three distinct Part D plans to choose from, one more than Anthem and AARP. That said, plan availability varies by location. We looked for Part D plans in Miami, Florida, and all three plans were available. We had access to the $0 deductible Humana Premier Rx Plan and monthly premiums ranged from $41.20 to $132.30 across all plans, so there were options for Medicare beneficiaries on different budgets.

» Save More: 8 tips to building a budget on a fixed income

However, one thing to consider is that all three plans received three-star ratings (i.e. Average) from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) for 2025. These ratings consider many important factors like the quality of customer service, overall member experience, accuracy of drug pricing, and how quickly members could get appointments. Though Anthem beat Humana’s CMS rating for 2025, Humana has historically received higher ratings than most other carriers, including Anthem and Cigna.

Humana’s Medicare Part D plans offer low overall costs, membership perks, and nationwide availability. If you travel often, take preferred generics, or enjoy mobile fitness apps, their plans may be worth considering. You may also qualify for a one-on-one, comprehensive review of the medications you take with a specialist through Humana’s Medication Therapy Management Program. This just goes to show that Humana cares about their customers’ well-being.

» Related Reading: Senior travel and vacations

Humana provides several other types of insurance for Medicare beneficiaries. You can check out our latest Humana Medigap review and Humana Medicare Advantage review for more information.

Our Experience With Anthem Part D

While coverage, deductibles, and premiums vary by location, Anthem only offers two Part D plans: Anthem MediBlue Rx Standard and Anthem MediBlue Rx Plus. The standard plan has a lower monthly premium and is generally recommended for those who take fewer medications (particularly Tiers 1 and 2), while the Plus plan has a higher premium and is recommended for those who take a wider range of medications (Tiers 1 through 5).

We researched plans in Los Angeles, California, and were quoted $135.60 per month with a $590 annual deductible for the Standard plan and $164.90 per month with a $120 annual deductible for the Plus plan. Though we would have liked to see a $0 deductible plan like Humana offers, both plans still offer solid value. There’s not a huge difference in premiums between the Standard and Plus plans, so it may be worth upgrading to Plus for Medicare beneficiaries who want to enjoy a lower deductible and a wider range of coverage for name-brand and generic drugs. Even though Humana generally receives higher ratings for its Medicare Advantage and Part D plans, both of the plans available to us had 3.5-star CMS ratings for 2025 (tied with Wellcare for the highest CMS rating on this list).

If you live in a state where Anthem is a carrier, they may be a solid choice to explore. We were impressed with the online experience, enrollment tutorials, health and wellness resources, and medication research tools. If you’re weighing your options on a stand-alone prescription drug plan versus a Medicare Part C plan with drug coverage, check out our Anthem Medicare Advantage plans review for more details.

Our Experience With Cigna Part D

Cigna offers three stand-alone Part D plans: Cigna Healthcare Saver Rx, Cigna Healthcare Assurance Rx, and Cigna Healthcare Extra Rx. We researched plans available in Chicago, Illinois, and we appreciated that all the plans offered ample benefits at different price points. The quoted monthly premiums were $16.60 (Saver), $65.40 (Assurance), and $101.60 (Extra). Cigna makes it easy to compare each plan based on what it offers.

While all three plans have a CMS rating of 2.5 stars for 2025, we liked that Cigna put this information just below the name of each plan. With most other carriers on this list, we had to look into plan documentation or dig up the CMS reports to get the star ratings. So, even though Anthem and Humana got higher overall ratings, we appreciate Cigna’s transparency.

Cigna is one of our recommendations for Medicare Part D carriers because of their pricing, plan coverage, and availability. You may be able to choose from three Part D plans, ranging in monthly premium prices and deductible costs. Cigna’s plans offer a $0 copay for Tier 1 preferred generic medications when you choose mail order from a pharmacy with preferred cost-sharing. That can add up to significant savings in money and time! Cigna also earns points for extras, such as ease of website navigation and added customer perks.

Check out our Cigna Medigap review and Cigna Medicare Advantage review for more details on Cigna’s other insurance offerings.

Our Experience With Wellcare Part D

We researched Wellcare’s PDPs in New York City and found that all three plans were available. We were quoted $38.70 per month for Value Script, $55.30 for Wellcare Classic, and $126.80 for Medicare Rx Value Plus. Though prices can vary a lot by location, these were higher than comparable plans from Cigna, though not quite as high as either Anthem plan. Much like Anthem’s Part D plans, all three Wellcare PDPs received 3.5-star ratings from CMS.

As one of the largest managed care organizations across the United States, Wellcare’s plan offerings, including their tiered Medicare Part D plans, are noteworthy. Their large pharmacy network rivals health care giants like Aetna and Cigna. Wellcare also delivers Medicare Advantage plans complete with dental, hearing, and vision benefits.

» Learn About: Affordable dental care for seniors

Check out our review of Wellcare Medicare Advantage plans to learn more about their insurance offerings.

Our Experience With Aetna Part D

Like Humana and Cigna, Aetna has three standalone Part D plans: SilverScript SmartSaver, SilverScript Choice, and SilverScript Plus. We researched premiums and benefits for applicants in Atlanta, Georgia, and got competitive quotes for all three plans. The monthly premium for SmartSaver was $15.70 per month, Choice was $52.60 per month, and Plus was $100.30 per month.

Like Cigna, Aetna shows the CMS star ratings of all plans upfront so you don’t have to go hunting for the information — something we really appreciate. All three plans for 2025 have three-star ratings, similar to the plans available through Humana. We also liked that all of Aetna’s plans were relatively affordable compared to carriers like AARP and Anthem. This means Aetna may be a great option for seniors and other Medicare beneficiaries who don’t want to pay a fortune for a PDP, but still want ample coverage for their prescription medications.

We feel Aetna may be a good option for your Medicare Part D plan if you are on a fixed income or looking for an extensive pharmacy selection because you travel frequently. It may also be a great choice if you currently take little to no medication but are looking for an affordable PDP so you won’t pay the late enrollment penalty down the line.

See our Aetna Medigap review and review of Aetna’s Medicare Advantage plans for more information.

Our Experience With AARP Part D

Like Anthem, AARP only offers two stand-alone Part D plans: Medicare Rx Saver from UHC and Medicare Rx Preferred from UHC. One downside to these plans is that, unlike most other carriers on this list, there are very few instances where the policyholder can enjoy $0 copays. We researched premiums and benefits in Houston, Texas, and were quoted $76.30 per month for the Saver plan and $89.20 per month for the Preferred plan.

Considering that the Preferred plan has a $0 annual deductible (compared to $590 with the Saver plan) and lower copays in most instances, we think the Preferred could offer a better value to most Medicare beneficiaries, even if you only take one or two medications. That said, AARP’s premiums are still a little high, especially when taking all the various copays into consideration. It’s important to note that AARP doesn’t require you to become an AARP member to enroll in a Part D or Medicare Advantage plan — this requirement only applies to AARP’s Medigap plans. However, we still think it’s worth the extra $12 per year for all the additional resources and senior discounts.

» Save More: Senior discounts in 2024

If you are an older adult looking for a Medicare Part D carrier, you may consider AARP prescription drug plans from UnitedHealthcare. Although the AARP MedicareRx Preferred PDP may have higher monthly premiums, it also has a $0 deductible across drug tiers, which may be worth the price in our book.

Check out our UnitedHealthcare review and AARP Medicare Advantage review for more information.